Hello, everyone! I recently took the plunge after 1000 or so changesets using iD to finally start trying out JOSM. I can definitely see how it’s more powerful though definitely a bit of a learning curve.
What I’m trying to figure out is how to do something that I find relatively easy in iD, of referencing outside information sources while editing. I’m not trying to import it directly, just look at the data in various places.
For example, say I want to look at the (public domain) MassGIS data on Massachusetts libraries. This is hosted on ArcGIS, and I can get the GeoJSON by downloading
In iD, what I can do is go to the Map Data tab on the right side, choose “Custom Map Data”, and put in that URL. Then all the points show up as magenta circles, and I can click them to look at the data while I edit. So I might use it as one source to figure out where the library is if it looks like it might be in the wrong spot (I think some in Massachusetts were imported long ago and have since moved, and I’ve fixed a couple of those), or to get a library’s web site to include that in OSM or so just look at for more information. I’m not doing any sort of “importing”, just using it as one additional source of data to reference.
I’m trying to figure out how to do the same sort of thing in JOSM. There’s a “Data” menu with “Open custom URL”, but that looks to be something different entirely. The main thing I think I’m supposed to do is to choose Open Location in the File menu and open that GeoJSON URL as a new layer. But once it’s in the new layer, it seems really tough to actually use. The points are really small and can be hard to pick out (as opposed to iD where the circles are bigger and can be easily seen at any zoom level), and I have to switch to it as the active layer in order to click the point and see its properties. So it looks like I need to switch to the GeoJSON layer to look at something, and then switch back to my “main” OSM layer in order to use the information. And while in the GeoJSON layer, I need to be careful to not accidentally move or edit anything, since JOSM is treating it as a data layer like any other I might want to modify.
So I guess I’m just trying to figure out if I understand the process right, and if there’s anything I can do to make things easier. Is there a way to mark a layer as “read-only”? Is there a way to look at properties on one layer while modifying another? Is there a way to make the points more noticeable than the tiny cyan squares which can be hard to see against some backgrounds? I’m guessing there’s a plugin or two to help me, since there look to be a bazillion of them, but I’m not even sure what the term is for what I’m looking for.
Thanks for any insight you can give. I was hoping that JOSM would make things easier for if I wanted to reference multiple sources, and to use some bigger files than I could manage to load into iD, and I’m guessing that it can once I’m used to it, but tips for how to most easily switch and handle the various layers would be appreciated.
3 posts - 3 participants
Ce sujet de discussion accompagne la publication sur https://community.openstreetmap.org/t/how-do-i-reference-geojson-data-easiest-in-josm/108418