Is there any legit reason why there can be both landuse + natural on the same area?

The title is what’s being observed, the most notable old mapped basins that have natural=water + landuse=basin. This one I know get’s flagged by I think Osmose and possibly ID Editor, but only when one mods the object proposing to upgrade the tags.

Created a JOSM toolbar button to search the larger data area (including edits in progress) and found half a dozen and cleaned them up.

If it’s an absolute I’d propose this to be made a (general) validation check. (May exist but not encountered AFAICR).

Please advise.

7 posts - 4 participants

Read full topic


Ce sujet de discussion accompagne la publication sur https://community.openstreetmap.org/t/is-there-any-legit-reason-why-there-can-be-both-landuse-natural-on-the-same-area/107000