Shoulder=* tag is confusing

It turns out that shoulder tag is used in a confusing way and makes hard to edit/use this data.

There is no clear way to mark something as full shoulder (enough to provide space for emergency parking) and something that is at most fitting or a walking pedestrian.

All of that is quite confusing, making hard to clarify situation for authors of editors as @westnordost discovered.

See for example

Shoulder quest is unclear · Issue #3613 · streetcomplete/StreetComplete · GitHub add shoulder overlay · Issue #4340 · streetcomplete/StreetComplete · GitHub Shoulder quest only on motorway and trunk in the Netherlands · Issue #4617 · streetcomplete/StreetComplete · GitHub

Posting this as I want to make people more aware that this is space that can benefit from some new tagging scheme.

As usually, it is too late to redefine shoulder tag - but maybe new ones can be added to make it possible to clearly tag and use this data?

21 posts - 10 participants

Read full topic

Ce sujet de discussion accompagne la publication sur